15 July 2010

Is this enough?


Everybody loves a halftime report, especially from the nearly defeated who wonder about the gall Chris Cohan must have not to grab his check and get the fuck out of Dodge already. But I digress. The Giants had a slightly disappointing first half with one horrible stretch and a relentlessly awful time within their own division, which kept them mired in mediocrity. Can they shock us all and rise above the pack? Let's have a look at the hitters-

Pablo Sandoval- the Internet buzz is that the panda is going through a divorce, which is just so depressing on any level for a 23-year old with a daughter, but it's even more upsetting when you ponder the goofy joy the man brings to the dugout. He is still strong at third, but he looks lost at the plate, especially from the right side. The cliche is that he is the big bat the Giants need in the second half, and they'd get it for nothing. Still, let's face it- he stunk, given what he did last year. C-

Juan Uribe- If Larry Kruger were still around, this man might get him fired again. Yes, he provided the early power that kept the boys in many games, but he hit a woeful slump in the last month that may (or may not) have been caused by a finger injury. Stop hacking at slop, Juan, and maybe we can talk Harvard at the end of the year. B

Edgar Renteria- I don't care what his batting average is (and throw out that first Houston series and where would he be?)- the man cannot hit. Did you see him bail out against Strasburg? My son has far more balls, and those pitchers are throwing from forty feet. The only reason he doesn't fail is that he's always hurt so he's not on the field hurting the team. He just collects checks. You have plenty to choose from, but this is arguably Sabean's worst signing. D-

Buster Posey- I saw him make plays at first that screamed "athlete." Watched him throw out runners and thought, Mr. Bench? Saw him hit homers deep into right-center and pondered, Our Saviour? He's not Will Clark yet, but allow the jaded some hope. A

Andres Torres- During one stretch he made an ESPN catch every night, and at times he is exactly the spark plug they need in the leadoff spot. He still strikes out too much and is prone to slump, but he's played far better than anyone thought he could. B+

Freddy Sanchez- If I hear one more person say "professional hitter" I'm going to gag harder than the last time I heard John Kerrey say "blood and treasure." Sanchez does, however, give you the impression he'll make contact. He's solid at the plate and in the field, and he does the little things a #2 hitter should do. Now get that average up and stay healthy. B

Eli Whiteside- a cult waiting to happen. The Billy Bob Thornton of baseball. How do you grade a phenomenon like this? A+ (for hair stylings and accent)

Nate Schierholtz- this was supposed to be the year, until it wasn't. I'm not sure if expectations for this local native are too high or he just can't handle prime time, but he's one of the biggest disappointments of the year. D

Aaron Rowand- Ain't it painful watching him hit? He looks like he can't get comfortable on an airplane toilet seat. He epitomizes this blog's title, and then once a month he'll hit a homer to save a game, which is more than Renteria does. D

Pat Burrell- in some ways, he's like a slight upgrade on Bengie Molina- he's old and slow and past his prime, but occasionally he hits for power when he's not striking out. Provided some stability in left when they needed it, but he is way too slow to roam the outfield and I'm guessing his slump is around the corner. B

Travis Ishikawa- can you sell your soul to the tao? For most of this man's career, I'd rather see Jonathan Sanchez pinch hit for him, but all of a sudden, he looks like he's found an approach. He said he spent hours in the tunnel hitting against a machine from thirty feet, and if that works I need to get junior back to the cages. He is still Travis Ishikawa and he's still only had 65 at-bats, but lately, some of those have been hits! Shocking! A-

Aubrey Huff- Is this guy really fifty years old? Is he the most grizzled man in professional sports? Well, he may also be the best bargain in the league, because his first half was all-star caliber for three million. That swing looks funky at times, especially when he's grounding to second, but his power numbers and clutch hitting have allowed this team to hang around. A

3 comments:

Tuna said...

Wow, you just keep giving and giving. And I've got nothing but baby thoughts. This is an amazingly indepth review of the Giants so far this season. Thanks for sharing. And I really mean it.

I have followed the Giants far less closely than the past few years for obvious reasons. If I had to give them a report card, I'd say they are if anything a bit better than I thought they would be. I love Huff. I get all tingly when I see Baumgardner and Posey chatting together. It give me hope about the future of this organization. And then Rowan strikes out.

What do we do? Wait for Renteria's contract to expire at the end of the year? Endure the utter fucking so cal flake that is Barry "candy Ass" Zito? Prey that someone will let us trade Rowan for a bag of resin and just get him our of here?

Sanchez is probably going to have to be traded for us to get another hitter. Ideally Darren Ford can be given a shot at the Big Leagues next year and come up roses. Fuck, I dont know. This year the giants will probably just miss the playoffs and Brian Sabean and Bichy will survive yet another year, somehow.

Final thought...I hated George Steinbrenner. In the words of Billy Martin, George was a convicted liar. IN the words of others Steinbrenner was a thin skinned, rich kid who knew almost nothing about baseball but couldnt keep his mouth shut about how his team should be run.

BUt here's the rub. He really, really cared about winning. He took it personally when his team underpreformed and he tried to fix it in his own ham fisted way when the Yankees came up short. I just cant see Billy Neukum or the other partners ever displaying that sort of passion. And its that lack of commitment to winning that hurts the Giants more than Renteria, Sabean or Philipino Heritage Night. In fact, its what allows enables each of those things.

Tuna said...

Hate to beat a dead horse, but ponder this.

Aaron Rowand OF $13.6mm yr, .240 BA, .285 OBP, .398 SLG

Andres Torres OF $426K yr, 277 BA, 372 OBP and 483 SLG

When you consider the limited nature of the Giants payroll, this sort of poor use of cash is just brutal. Its the not just that Rowan sucks, its that he's the second highest paid player on the team and shouldn't even be starting. That money could be spent on so many other better players. And its bc of his enormous contract that Darren Ford hasn't been given a shot.

Just brutal.

Tuna said...

For some reason part of my email cutoff. I listed other Giants OF's numbers which were better than Rowan's and yet made far far less money. You get the point. Go Gigantes.